New work, step by step paintings, and painting how to tips from my teaching experience

A Painting is Never Finished, Only Abandoned

Sun on the River  12 x 16 oil (c) Lee McVey
Sun on the River 12 x 16 oil (c) Lee McVey

A painting is never finished; it is only abandoned. I first heard this quote of Leonardo da Vinci's many years ago in a workshop taught by Richard McKinley. As I continue on my painting journey, I find this sentiment is so true. A painting I can think is finished, may look unresolved just an hour later, a day later, or months later.

I can't count the number of times I have looked and pondered over a painting on my easel, then decided it was finished and taken it off the easel. As soon as it is on the wall, I see it isn't finished to my satisfaction. A slight change of environment can give me fresh eyes to see the painting differently.

Sun on the River, above left, is one of my recent oils that has gone through changes as I take it off the easel and put it back on the easel again. I work on it, let it sit and work on it yet again. I thought it was finished and took it for a critique by an artist whose work I deeply respect. After that discussion, I decided I could call this painting finished, as in abandoned, or I could work on it again.

I decided to work on the painting, so I reduced some of the detail and light on the left side. I darkened the upper left background to minimize the contrast and took out some of the tree trunks and softened the light on the trees on the left side. I also made subtle changes to the left side of the river's bank. All of this was done to keep the viewer's eye on my center of interest,  which I want to be the light on the trees and background on the right.

During the critique discussion, we talked about cropping the left portion off and making the painting a square to definitely keep the viewer's eye where I want it to be. At this point, I am abandoning the painting, but I may try a new canvas with the image in a square format.

Below is one of the painting's earlier versions.




Comments

18 Responses to A Painting is Never Finished, Only Abandoned

This is the history of artists everywhere.
One time after several years of face to wall painting...I was looking for something else
and this painting was so "old' i pulled it out,put it on the easel, the phone range down stairs. When I came back.15 minutes later and saw exactly what the painting needed and 20 minutes later it was done.

Another time, i found a painting put it on the easel... walked out without looking at it...came back to find the reason that I couldn't finish it was because it WAS finished.

Glad to learn that da Vinci said it first. A friend when walking through my home asked if the painting she was looking at was finished...my reply was as long as it is hanging on my wall it is not finished. She then proceeded to give me a very helpful critique which I sincerely appreciated.

Too bad it isn't pastel. You could just cut the paper and make it square!

No doubt about it in my mind... You've really made it a lot better!!!

Marilyn, It would be easier to make it square by cutting, but I'd miss importance of and the fun of redesigning the painting. When I do it as a square, I think it would be best to redesign the composition rather than copy part of the painting. Thank you for commenting.

Joe, Thank you for commenting. I agree, sometimes "new eyes" are all that's needed to finish a painting.

Sue. Thank you for your comment. Critiques are very helpful to us. I'm glad you had a good one for the painting on your wall.

Sue. Thank you for your comment. Critiques are very helpful to us. I'm glad you had a good one for the painting on your wall.

Joe, Thank you for writing. I agree, sometimes "new eyes" are all that's needed to see what a painting needs.

Marilyn, Thank you for commenting. It would be easier if it were pastel so I could cut the paper, but I'd miss the fun of painting another version. Besides, redesigning the composition for a square format would be better, I think, than copying part of the painting. Sometimes cropping works, but I like the left side shadow on the water and would want to see if I could incorporate more of that into a new format.

Marian, I appreciate your comments. Thank you.

plz stop

So glad you could put my quote to use. Keep up the great work and you will become as good as me!!!

--Leonardo Da Vinci

wow

Please do not try to copy me...

:D

Write another comment . . .

Write another comment . . .


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post