New work, step by step paintings, and painting how to tips from my teaching experience

Cropping Paintings for New Compositions

Mesa Blanca Winter Light,  cropped
Mesa Blanca Winter Light, cropped

This afternoon, I was looking through a stack of pastel paintings with the thought of tossing out those I didn't think were successful. I stopped at a couple of plein air studies I had done on a January day at Mesa Blanca in San Ysidro, northwest of Albuquerque. I didn't think they were successful enough to keep, but yet, I didn't really want to destroy them. I remembered the day I painted them with fond memories because the winter day was relatively warm and the light on the snowy mesa was captivating.

I played around with a cropping them various ways to see if that made a difference in my opinion of the paintings. Above left is the image of my first painting after cropping. Below is how it originally looked. I was initially attracted to the sweep of the field leading up to the light on the snow on the mesa. To keep it in this compositional format, I think changes need to be made to make it more successful. But it's easier to crop it!

In the second painting, shown below, I painted the line of the mesa meeting the sky as it really was, but the expanded "W" shape bothers me. I think this was a situation in which it would have been best to do what worked better for the painting rather than adhering to reality. This view is immediately to the right of the first one. I didn't even have to move my easel.

Experimenting with the cropping tool and the clone tool in Photoshop, I made the image a square and changed the sky line. I like it better this way.

For both paintings, this has been a planning exercise for larger studio paintings based on my plein air studies and reference photos. I haven't decided if I will use oil or pastel for the bigger paintings, but I do know this just the jumping off spot. Undoubtedly, I'll make other changes and adjustments in composition and color in the studio paintings.

As for the task of tossing out paintings, I did toss several and pulled others to work up into larger studio paintings. A few other plein air studies looked better to me than I had remembered them so I am planning to frame them.


Comments

4 Responses to Cropping Paintings for New Compositions

Hello Lee...

A good post to remind us of cropping a painting if not happy with with a painting before throwing into the dreaded trash can.
Sometimes I put them away to look at another day, another year. Funny, how one gets a totally different perspective on the painting.

Years ago, I had a friend who use to check my trash can for thrown away watercolor works..
She asked if I minded if she took them since they were being thrown out anyway. I told her what I disliked about them, she disagreed.
When she and her husband moved away and I visited her home, all those paintings were beautifully framed and hanging on their walls. Good grief!! I sure did see them under a different light. Could not remember why I had thrown them in the trash..and did not see why I had. Not that they were great paintings...but the thing is, we never know what others see or feel when they look at a painting. Not even ourself after a year of not seeing a supposedly discarded painting.

I always learn from your posts, Lee. I definitely see the improvement in the first and when you discussed the second, I was reminded of using tools like Photoshop to change things up and to make better studio pieces.
My friend, Sharon Weaver, does that frequently, but I rarely do... Not sure why. It certainly is a good practice!!

Hello Sandy, thank you for reading and commenting. I don't know how I'd feel if someone wanted the paintings I decided to trash. Don't think I would be comfortable with it, even after this experience of thinking some work was better than I thought it had been. If I decided not to toss, then if someone wanted it, I'd be okay with that.

Marian, thank you for reading my blog. I'm pleased you learn something from my posts! I guess I forgot to include what the photoshopped image looked like. Using Photoshop is a good tool for composing, but I often forget to use it. When I do use it, I always wonder why I don't use it more often.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post